----- Original Message -----
From: "Russell Stronach" [log in to unmask]
To: [log in to unmask]
Sent: Tuesday, October 05, 2004 3:16 PM
Subject: BBC E-mail: Hospital autism detention 'wrong'
Russell Stronach saw this story on BBC News Online and thought you should
see it.
** Message **
This just came over on the Radio 4 three o'clock news.
** Hospital autism detention 'wrong' **
The detention of a man with autism was a breach of his human rights, a court
has ruled.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/em/fr/-/1/hi/health/3717544.stm
Hospital autism detention 'wrong'
The detention of a man with autism under common law was a breach of his
human rights, a court has ruled.
The European Court of Human Rights ruling may have implications for as many
as 50,000 people being cared for in UK nursing homes and hospitals.
The man was detained at a Surrey hospital in 1997 after he was deemed
incapable of consenting to treatment.
He had no right to appeal, unlike if he had been held under the Mental
Health Act.
The common law allows a single doctor to recommend the detention of patients
incapable of consenting to treatment if it is in their best interests.
Under the Mental Health Act, patients are entitled to appeal to a tribunal
for release.
This ruling says it is wrong and denies a person their liberty
Solicitor Robert Robinson
But no such entitlement exists for the thousands of people admitted to
hospitals and nursing homes under common law for conditions such as dementia
and learning disabilities.
As the man, known as HL, cannot speak, his legal team argued he was
incapable of resisting detention and it was against his right to liberty
under the European Convention of Human Rights.
Mr L's solicitor Robert Robinson said the decision could have "huge
implications" for the UK.
Wrong
"When people are admitted to hospital under common law, doctors will have to
consider whether people are being detained.
"The key is whether they are actually detained rather than just admitted
under the common law.
"If they are detained, this ruling says it is wrong and denies a person
their liberty."
It is more costly and time consuming to admit people under the Mental Health
Act and some families prefer patients to be treated under common law because
of the stigma associated with detention on mental health grounds.
Mr Robinson said the carers, a family who have looked after Mr L since 1994,
were delighted at the decision.
"It has taken a long time and been heard by four different courts, the
family are obviously pleased at the result."
No damages were awarded.
Challenge
Mr L was admitted to Bournewood hospital in July 1997 after staff at a day
centre became worried about his behaviour.
He was released after nearly five months following a Court of Appeal
challenge by his carers.
The court ruled his detention was unlawful but the House of Lords overturned
the decision in 1998.
In 2001, the Health Service Ombudsman found there was no justification for
detaining Mr L.
Mental health charity Mind agreed the ruling could have a huge impact on the
UK.
A spokeswoman said: "As many as 50,000 people in hospital and nursing homes
are potentially affected because - either though disability or illness -
they lack the mental capacity to give informed consent to their treatment.
"The government has pledged in the past to tackle this issue, although
current proposals lack strong enough safeguards to prevent the type of
situation faced by Mr L.
"People who would otherwise be to all intents and purposes indefinitely
detained need detailed care plans and regular reviews of their treatment.
"They cannot be simply left and forgotten about."
Story from BBC NEWS:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/1/hi/health/3717544.stm
Published: 2004/10/05 14:10:17 GMT
© BBC MMIV
____________________________________________________________________________
This email and all attachments have been scanned by Kingston Communications'
email Anti-Virus service and no known viruses were detected.
____________________________________________________________________________
________________End of message______________________
Archives and tools for the Disability-Research Discussion List
are now located at:
www.jiscmail.ac.uk/lists/disability-research.html
You can JOIN or LEAVE the list from this web page.
|