First, let me state that I think we should all thank and support Peter in his
attempts to maintain this network as it was intended.
However, I do think that social history, including research into family
history, has a valid place in mining history. I find, for example, Ian
Tyler's books more readable and interesting due to his inclusion of the
social side of things.
Alan Trevarthen's contribution shows how research often involves going off on
a tangent, leading to new finds, which would not be made if the original
study had not been made. Conversely, members could just as easily unearth
social information while making other enquiries, which may be of great value
to someone else. It can make so much difference just being told where and
where not to look.
This network is all about the exchange of information, and someone who is
researching their family history today may be perfectly placed to answer
another persons questions tomorrow.
I must stress that while obviously not wanting to ban such enquiries I do not
want to see the network turn into some sort of genealogical society either.
Surely a balance can be reached.
I hope all this does not cause trouble!
Richard Amies.
|