Before you challenge observe for a while. It's certainly not
a good thing when people react to the list by leaving or retreating into
silence.
Yes thank you Mark, but it's more serious if you are removed from a list
than if you leave voluntarily. I don't know Scott from Adam, but his
contributions i've seen attempt a critique of various post ism's and depth
of knowledge of poetics and a tentative attempt to suggest that class
divisions have not gone away. His stance therefore includes confrontation
but I don't see that that is all it is. Although he obviously has rubbed
Roddy and Joseph up who called him a middle class, stalinist, lefty slumming
it pimple etc. My point still is that our 1 list owner threatens Scott with
removal and calls for Joseph to come back. Joseph who Phil the day before
had said sent him weeks worth of hate mail. I am suggesting therefore and
forgive me if Scott has said things that i've missed, that as Scott seems
not to be the major rude-boy transgressor that our 1 list owner has made a
tactical/political decision that I disagree with and well...this might have
something to do with being a UN moderator.
best
paul
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
|